Special Retirement & Roth

General TSP Discussion.

Moderator: Aitrus

Post Reply
mmmmmbeer
Posts: 917
Joined: Wed May 11, 2016 11:00 am

Special Retirement & Roth

Post by mmmmmbeer »

So... the scenerio I have in my brain right now for you Special Retirement folks.

Say you are hypothetically someone who has roughly 300k in your tsp.. and say 7-ish years to go until you hit minimum retirement of 50 years old and have at least 20+ years of covered service. (your own numbers and years left into this for your scenerio)

With the new TSP rule coming into place in less than 2 years that will allow you upon retirement to stipulate which TSP balance to draw from, it makes a lot of sense to now go 100% Roth TSP contributions if you can.

In this hypothetical scenerio... in 7 years @ 12% RoR, the subjects TSP Account is roughly valued at $930,000 ($718,000 traditional /$212,000 Roth).

At that point you are 50, can retire and elect to draw specificially/only from your traditional tsp balance of $718k.

You allow your Roth balance to grow an additional 9.5 years, unfettered @ (hopefully) 12% a year giving you a nice untaxable balance of $588,000 @ 59.5 years old.

Additionally say @ 50 you want to retire and start drawing $6,000 a month from your traditional balance of $718k. Well if you can maintain that 12% RoR, your balance (even with zero new monies going in and the 6k/month draw) will continue to grow and at 59.5 yo when you can dip into your roth unpenalized, your traditional balance will have grown to $870k.

Not to shabby for being retired for 9.5 years, all the while drawing your pension, SS supplement + an additional $72k a year from your tsp balance.

So.. that's the dream for those hypotheticals out there anyway! :)

Young and old LEOs, Firefighters, ATC's run your scenerios... if you have a decent traditional balance already and a few years left... maybe think about the 100% Roth option now.
Those who 'abjure' violence can do so only because others are committing violence on their behalf.

mindofmush
Posts: 353
Joined: Mon Jul 02, 2012 1:38 pm

Re: Special Retirement & Roth

Post by mindofmush »

Looks like you've found the yellow brick road, good plan.
mo meng, mo ching (which loosely means: no money, no life)

User avatar
cswift01
Posts: 819
Joined: Thu Dec 08, 2016 10:46 am

Re: Special Retirement & Roth

Post by cswift01 »

mmmmmbeer wrote:So... the scenerio I have in my brain right now for you Special Retirement folks.

Say you are hypothetically someone who has roughly 300k in your tsp.. and say 7-ish years to go until you hit minimum retirement of 50 years old and have at least 20+ years of covered service. (your own numbers and years left into this for your scenerio)

With the new TSP rule coming into place in less than 2 years that will allow you upon retirement to stipulate which TSP balance to draw from, it makes a lot of sense to now go 100% Roth TSP contributions if you can.

In this hypothetical scenerio... in 7 years @ 12% RoR, the subjects TSP Account is roughly valued at $930,000 ($718,000 traditional /$212,000 Roth).

At that point you are 50, can retire and elect to draw specificially/only from your traditional tsp balance of $718k.

You allow your Roth balance to grow an additional 9.5 years, unfettered @ (hopefully) 12% a year giving you a nice untaxable balance of $588,000 @ 59.5 years old.

Additionally say @ 50 you want to retire and start drawing $6,000 a month from your traditional balance of $718k. Well if you can maintain that 12% RoR, your balance (even with zero new monies going in and the 6k/month draw) will continue to grow and at 59.5 yo when you can dip into your roth unpenalized, your traditional balance will have grown to $870k.

Not to shabby for being retired for 9.5 years, all the while drawing your pension, SS supplement + an additional $72k a year from your tsp balance.

So.. that's the dream for those hypotheticals out there anyway! :)

Young and old LEOs, Firefighters, ATC's run your scenerios... if you have a decent traditional balance already and a few years left... maybe think about the 100% Roth option now.
What about your 5% match?

mmmmmbeer
Posts: 917
Joined: Wed May 11, 2016 11:00 am

Re: Special Retirement & Roth

Post by mmmmmbeer »

cswift01 wrote: What about your 5% match?

That always goes traditional and was counted in the figuring.
Those who 'abjure' violence can do so only because others are committing violence on their behalf.

ATCJAX
Posts: 2
Joined: Mon Dec 18, 2017 12:29 pm

Re: Special Retirement & Roth

Post by ATCJAX »

Is the proposed change definitely happening? What is the effective date and where can I find a link? Thanks

floridabre
Posts: 24
Joined: Thu Sep 11, 2014 7:48 am

Re: Special Retirement & Roth

Post by floridabre »

it is my understanding that TSP only allows proportional withdrawal (traditional and roth) - although as a non LEO i havent really looked at the rules for LEO retirement).

mmmmmbeer
Posts: 917
Joined: Wed May 11, 2016 11:00 am

Re: Special Retirement & Roth

Post by mmmmmbeer »

ATCJAX wrote:Is the proposed change definitely happening? What is the effective date and where can I find a link? Thanks
They have up to 2 years to effect the changes.

http://www.fedweek.com/fedweek/tsp-with ... -date-yet/
Those who 'abjure' violence can do so only because others are committing violence on their behalf.

User avatar
evilanne
Posts: 2067
Joined: Thu May 14, 2015 6:52 pm

Re: Special Retirement & Roth

Post by evilanne »

Keep an eye on https://www.federalregister.gov/agencie ... ment-board. Any proposed rules should be published here when available.

mindofmush
Posts: 353
Joined: Mon Jul 02, 2012 1:38 pm

Re: Special Retirement & Roth

Post by mindofmush »

mmmmmbeer wrote:
In this hypothetical scenerio... in 7 years @ 12% RoR, the subjects TSP Account is roughly valued at $930,000 ($718,000 traditional /$212,000 Roth).

At that point you are 50, can retire and elect to draw specificially/only from your traditional tsp balance of $718k.

You allow your Roth balance to grow an additional 9.5 years, unfettered @ (hopefully) 12% a year giving you a nice untaxable balance of $588,000 @ 59.5 years old.

Additionally say @ 50 you want to retire and start drawing $6,000 a month from your traditional balance of $718k. Well if you can maintain that 12% RoR, your balance (even with zero new monies going in and the 6k/month draw) will continue to grow and at 59.5 yo when you can dip into your roth unpenalized, your traditional balance will have grown to $870k.
1) I think going 100% Roth for the next 7-ish years will save money over doing a Traditional to Roth conversion later because of the expected 12% or better RoR.

2) I think that at 59.5 that you should NOT start withdrawing from the RothTSP side but let it grow larger. (And move the RothTSP to a Roth IRA by age 70 to avoid RMDs.) Increases in income should come from the TradTSP side. This might lower your Traditional balance which can lower your forced income tax increases due to RMDs beginning age 70.5.

I think the two biggest advantages of a Roth IRA is no RMDs and the tax free transfer of money to beneficiaries. To me, this means saving the Roth money till after age 70.5 to spend.

If you need a tax reduction vehicle (because of 100% Roth contributions), consider high deductible health plans and max the medical account.

User avatar
evilanne
Posts: 2067
Joined: Thu May 14, 2015 6:52 pm

Re: Special Retirement & Roth

Post by evilanne »

I like mindofmush's perspective, especially with a high RoR. Also, recent tax changes (3% reduction to 15%, 25% brackets & 4% reduction to 28% bracket) are temporary so putting more into Roth and letting it grow could be more advantageous if the changes revert back around 2025/2026. I doubt they will ever go lower in the future given increase in national debt. Having a good mix of Traditional & Roth gives you more flexibility in retirement to manage your tax burden year to year as needed.

Post Reply

Fund Prices2024-04-18

FundPriceDayYTD
G $18.19 0.01% 1.27%
F $18.62 -0.30% -3.14%
C $78.45 -0.21% 5.50%
S $76.12 -0.20% -1.27%
I $40.67 0.02% 1.21%
L2065 $15.58 -0.13% 3.04%
L2060 $15.58 -0.13% 3.04%
L2055 $15.58 -0.13% 3.04%
L2050 $31.35 -0.13% 2.44%
L2045 $14.32 -0.12% 2.35%
L2040 $52.37 -0.11% 2.29%
L2035 $13.85 -0.10% 2.21%
L2030 $46.21 -0.09% 2.15%
L2025 $12.93 -0.05% 1.72%
Linc $25.28 -0.04% 1.51%

Live Charts

Pending Allocations

Under development. For now, you may view Pending Allocations by going to "fantasy TSP" and selecting "Leaderboard sort" of "Pending Allocations".